MDIschools.net

Commissioner’s Responses to December 1 Reorganization Submissions

(Source: Maine Department of Education, 12/20/2007)

County	Submitted Configuration	Type of Plan – Student Count	Configuration meets criteria in the law	Commissioner’s 12/15 ruling	Senator	Representative
Androscoggin	Auburn	Alternative – 3,478	Yes	Incomplete	Snowe-Mello
Androscoggin	Lewiston	Alternative – 4,701	Yes	Incomplete	Rotundo	Makas*
Androscoggin	MSAD 52 (Greene, Leeds, Turner)	Alternative – 2,182	Yes	Incomplete	Nutting	Sirois Lansley Knight
Androscoggin, Franklin	Jay, MSAD 36 (Livermore, Livermore Falls)	Reorganization – 1,868	Yes	Incomplete	Bryant Nutting	Knight
Androscoggin. Kennebec	Sabattus, Wales, Litchfield, Oak Hill CSD (Union 44)	Reorganization – 1,601	Yes	Incomplete	Nutting McCormick	Lansley Smith
Aroostook	Bridgewater	Reorganization – 56	No	Does not comply	Sherman	Lundeen
Aroostook	Caribou, MSAD 20 (Fort Fairfield), Caswell, Westmanland, Stockholm, New Sweden, Woodland, Limestone (Union 122)	Reorganization – 2,747	Yes	Incomplete	Sherman Martin	Edgecomb* Ayotte Lundeen
Aroostook	Easton	Reorganization – 223	No	Does not comply	Sherman	Lundeen
Aroostook	MSAD 1 (Castle Hill, Chapman, Mapleton, Presque Isle, Westfield), MSAD 32 (Ashland, Garfield Plt, Masardis, Oxbow Plt, Portage Lake)	Reorganization – 2,398	Yes	Incomplete	Sherman	Sutherland* Lundeen
Aroostook	MSAD 10 (Allagash), MSAD 24( *), MSAD 27 (Eagle Lake, Fort Kent, New Canada, Saint Francis, Saint John Plt, Wallagrass, Winterville Plt), MSAD 33 (Frenchville, Saint Agatha), Grand Isle, Madawaska	Reorganization – 2,110	Yes	Incomplete	Martin	Ayotte
Aroostook	MSAD 14 (Danforth, Weston), MSAD 25 (Mount Chase, Patten, Sherman, Stacyville), MSAD 29 (Hammond, Houlton, Littleton, Monticello), MSAD 70 (Amity, Cary Plt, Haynesville, Hodgdon, Linneus, Ludlow, New Limerick), CSD 9 (Dyer Brook), Orient, Hersey, Moro, Bancroft (Union 108)	Reorganization – 2,863	Yes	Incomplete	Sherman	Sutherland* McLeod Joy
Aroostook	MSAD 24 (Van Buren, Hamlin, Cyr Plantation)	Refuses to Submit  (404)	No plan submitted	Not in compliance	Martin	Ayotte
Aroostook	MSAD 42 (Mars Hill, Blaine, Bridgewater, E Plantation)	Reorganization – 398	No	Does not comply	Sherman	Sutherland* Lundeen
Aroostook	MSAD 45 (Washburn, Perham, Wade)	Reorganization - 414	No	Does not comply	Martin	Sutherland*
Aroostook	Nashville Plantation	Reorganization – 13	No	Does not comply	Martin	Jackson
Cumberland	Brunswick	Alternative -  3,132	Yes	Incomplete	Edmonds
Cumberland	Cape Elizabeth	Alternative – 1,795	Yes	Incomplete	Bromley
Cumberland	Falmouth, MSAD 51 (Cumberland, North Yarmouth)	Reorganization – 4,419	Yes	Incomplete	Turner	Burgess* Savage
Cumberland	Gorham	Alternative – 2,736	Yes	Incomplete	Bartlett	Farrington*
Cumberland	MSAD 61 (Bridgton, Casco, Naples, Sebago)	Alternative – 2,058	Yes	Incomplete	Hastings	Cebra Sykes
Cumberland	Portland	Alternative – 7,040	Yes	Incomplete	Brannigan Strimling	Harlow*
Cumberland	Raymond, Westbrook, Windham	Reorganization – 6,040	Yes	Incomplete	Diamond Bartlett
Cumberland	Scarborough	Alternative – 3,313	Yes	Incomplete	Bartlett Bromley	McDonough
Cumberland	South Portland	Alternative – 3,071	Yes	Incomplete	Bromley
Cumberland	Yarmouth	Alternative – 1,386	Yes	Incomplete	Turner
Cumberland, Androscoggin	Freeport, MSAD 62 (Pownal), Durham (part Union 30) [Freeport Families for Education]	Reorganization – 1,931	Yes	Incomplete	Snowe-Mello	Vaughan Webster
Cumberland, Androscoggin	MSAD 15 (Gray, New Gloucester), Poland, Minot, Mechanic Falls ( Union 29)	Reorganization – 3,680	Yes	Incomplete	Nutting Snowe-Mello Turner	Cebra Hamper Sirois Vaughan
Franklin	Carrabassett Valley	Letter (87)	No	Does not comply	Gooley	Pinkham
Franklin, Kennebec, Somerset	MSAD 9 (Chesterville, Farmington, Industry, New Sharon, New Vineyard, Temple, Vienna, Weld, Wilton), MSAD 58 (Avon, Eustis, Kingfield, Phillips, Strong), Coplin Plt, Highland Plt	Reorganization – 3,163	Yes	Incomplete	Gooley Mills*	Saviello Pinkham Carter Mills Pineau
Franklin, Oxford	Rangeley (Union 37)	Alternative – 150	No	Does not comply	Gooley	Carter
Franklin, Oxford	Rangeley Plantation (Union 37)	Alternative – 17	No	Does not comply	Gooley	Carter
Franklin, Oxford	Dallas Plantation (Union 37)	Alternative –  39	No	Does not comply	Gooley	Carter
Franklin, Oxford	Lincoln Plantation (Union 37)	Alternative – 2	No	Does not comply	Bryant	Carter
Franklin, Oxford	Magalloway Plantation (Union 37)	Alternative – 1	No	Does not comply	Bryant	Carter
Franklin, Oxford	Sandy River Plantation (Union 37	Alternative – 11	No	Does not comply	Gooley	Patrick
Hancock	Sedgwick, Penobscot, Deer Isle, Stonington, Brooksville, Brooklin, Blue Hill, Castine (Unions 76, 93)	Pending (1,320)	Pending	Pending	Damon Rosen	Schatz Pingree
Hancock	Southwest Harbor, Mt Desert, Bar Harbor, Tremont, Mt Desert CSD, Frenchboro, MSAD 76 (Swans Island), Cranberry Isles (Union 98)	Reorganization – 1,462	Yes	Does not comply --(MDI RPC’s response)	Damon	Pingree Koffman
Hancock	Ellsworth	Reorganization – 1,035	No	Does not comply	Damon	Crosthwaite
Hancock	Hancock, Lamoine, Mariaville, Otis, Surry, Trenton, MSAD 26 (Eastbrook, Waltham) (Union 92)	Reorganization – 1,262	No	Does not comply	Damon Rosen Raye	McFadden* Eaton Crosthwaite
Hancock, Washington	Airline CSD (Aurora, Amherst, Great Pond, Osborn)	Letter (68)	No	Does not comply	Rosen	McFadden*
Hancock	Bucksport, Orland, MSAD 18 (Prospect, Verona)	Reorganization – 1,255	Yes	Incomplete	Weston Rosen	Rosen
Kennebec	Augusta	Alternative – 2,361	Yes	Incomplete	Mitchell*	Browne Silsby
Kennebec	Chelsea (part Union 132)	Letter (407)	No	Does not comply	McCormick	Miller
Kennebec	Manchester, Mount Vernon, Readfield, Wayne, CSD 10 (Maranacook), Fayette, Winthrop (Union 42)	Reorganization – 2,429	Yes	Incomplete	McCormick Gooley	Flood Knight
Kennebec	MSAD 11 (Gardiner, Pittston, Randolph, West Gardiner)	Alternative – 2,223	Yes	Incomplete	McCormick	Rines Treat
Kennebec	MSAD 47 (Belgrade, Oakland, Sidney, Rome), Waterville, China, Vassalboro, Winslow (Union 52)	Reorganization – 7,349	Yes	Incomplete	Mitchell* Marraché	Finch* Cotta Browne
Kennebec, Sagadahoc, Lincoln	MSAD 16 (Farmingdale, Hallowell), Monmouth, Dresden, Richmond	Reorganization – 2,450	Yes	Incomplete	McCormick Benoit	Smith Rines Treat
Knox	MSAD 5 (Owls Head, Rockland, South Thomaston), MSAD 50 (Cushing, Saint George, Thomaston)	Reorganization – 2,312	Yes	Incomplete	Savage
Knox, Lincoln	MSAD 40 (Friendship, Union, Waldoboro, Warren, Washington)	Alternative – 1,970	Yes	Incomplete	Dow	Pieh
Knox, Waldo	Five Town CSD (Appleton, Camden, Hope, Lincolnville, Rockport), MSAD #28 (Camden, Rockport) (Union 69)	Reorganization – 2,048	Yes	Incomplete	Savage Weston	Walker Miramant
Lincoln	Boothbay, Boothbay Harbor CSD, Bremen, Bristol, Damariscotta, Edgecomb, Great Salt Bay CSD, Jefferson, Newcastle, Nobleboro, South Bristol, Southport (Unions 49, 74, part Union 132)	Reorganization – 2,740	Yes	Incomplete	Dow	McKane Pieh MacDonald
Lincoln, Sagadahoc	Alna, Wiscasset, Westport Island, Palermo, Somerville, Whitefield, Windsor (Union 133, part Union 132)	Reorganization – 2,033	Yes	Incomplete	Dow Weston	MacDonald Browne Piotti Rines
Oxford	Gilead	Alternative – 37	No	Does not comply	Bryant	Carter
Oxford	MSAD 21 (Canton, Carthage, Dixfield, Peru), MSAD 39 (Buckfield, Hartford, Sumner), MSAD 43 (Byron, Mexico, Roxbury, Rumford), Hanover	Reorganization – 3,239	Yes	Incomplete	Gooley	Hotham
Oxford	MSAD 44 (Andover, Bethel, Greenwood, Newry, Woodstock)	Alternative – 823	No	Does not comply	Bryant	Millett Patrick
Oxford	MSAD 72 (Brownfield, Denmark, Fryeburg, Lovell, Stoneham, Stow, Sweden)	Alternative – 1,341	Yes	Incomplete	Hastings	Muse* Sykes
Oxford	Upton	Alternative – 7	No	Does not comply	Bryant	Carter
Oxford, Cumberland	MSAD 17 (Harrison, Hebron, Norway, Otisfield, Oxford, Paris, Waterford, West Paris)	Alternative – 3,650	Yes	Incomplete	Hastings	Millett Hamper Sirois Sykes
Oxford, York, Cumberland	MSAD 55 (Baldwin, Cornish, Hiram, Parsonsfield, Porter)	Alternative – 1,285	Yes	Incomplete	Nass Hastings	Muse*
Penobscot	Alton, Bradley, Greenbush, Milford, Old Town, Orono (Union 90, part Union 87) [Friends of Orono Schools list-serv]	Reorganization – 2,661	Yes	Incomplete	Schneider	Cain Dunn Duchesne Pratt
Penobscot	Glenburn	Letter	No	Does not comply	Plowman	Greeley
Penobscot	Bangor	Alternative – 3,830	Yes	Incomplete	Perry	Norton* Dunn
Penobscot	MSAD 23 (Carmel, Levant), Hermon	Reorganization – 1,869	Yes	Incomplete	Plowman Perry
Penobscot	Veazie (part Union 87)	Letter  (290)	No	Does not comply	Schneider	Dunn
Penobscot, Aroostook	MSAD 30 (Lee, Springfield, Webster Plt, Winn), MSAD 31 (Burlington, Edinburg, Enfield, Howland, Lowell, Maxfield, Passadumkeag), MSAD 67 (Chester, Lincoln, Mattawamkeag), Carroll Plt, Drew Plt, Reed Plt, Macwahoc, East Millinocket, Lakeville, Lowell, Seboeis, Medford, Glenwood Plt, Medway, Millinocket, Woodville (Unions 110, 113)	Reorganization – 3,417	Yes	Incomplete	Raye Smith Sherman	McLeod Clark Joy Gifford
Penobscot, Hancock	Brewer, Dedham, Orrington, SAD 63 (Clifton, Eddington, Holden) (Union 91)	Reorganization – 3,228	Yes	Incomplete	Rosen	Rosen Pratt
Penobscot, Piscataquis	MSAD 41 (Atkinson, Brownville, Lagrange, Milo)	Letter (727)	No	Does not comply	Smith Schneider	Annis Duchesne
Penobscot, Piscataquis	MSAD 64 (Bradford, Corinth, Hudson, Kenduskeag, Stetson)	Alternative – 1,283	No	Does not comply	Schneider	Duchesne Tardy
Penobscot, Somerset	MSAD 38 (Dixmont, Etna), MSAD 48 (Corinna, Hartland, Newport, Palmyra, Plymouth, Saint Albans)	Reorganization – 2,497	Yes	Incomplete	Plowman Smith	Tardy
Penobscot, Waldo	MSAD 22 (Hampden, Newburgh, Winterport)	Alternative – 2,222	Yes	Incomplete	Plowman Weston	Thibodeau
Piscataquis, Somerset	MSAD 4 (Abbot, Cambridge, Guilford, Parkman, Sangerville, Wellington) , MSAD 46 (Dexter, Exeter, Garland, Ripley), Harmony, Willimantic	Reorganization – 1,942	Yes	Incomplete	Smith	Tardy Thomas
Piscataquis, Somerset	MSAD 68 (Charleston, Dover-Foxcroft, Monson, Sebec), Greenville, Shirley, Beaver Cove, Kingsbury Plantation, Bowerbank, Lake View Plt (Union 60)	Reorganization – 1,303	Yes	Incomplete	Smith	Thomas
Sagadahoc	Bath, West Bath, Woolwich, Phippsburg, Arrowsic (Union 47)	Reorganization – 2,353 (under LD 910)	Yes	Complete^5(under LD 910)	Benoit	MacDonald
Sagadahoc	Georgetown	Alternative – 118	No	Does not comply	Benoit	MacDonald
Sagadahoc, Androscoggin	MSAD 75 (Bowdoin, Bowdoinham, Harpswell, Topsham), Lisbon (part Union 30)	Reorganization – 4,383	Yes	Incomplete	Nutting	Vaughan
Somerset	MSAD 54 (Canaan, Cornville, Mercer, Norridgewock, Skowhegan, Smithfield)	Alternative – 2,851	Yes	Incomplete	Mills*	Finch*
Somerset, Kennebec	MSAD 49 (Albion, Benton, Clinton, Fairfield)	Alternative – 2,669	Yes	Incomplete	Mills*	Finch* Cotta
Somerset, Piscataquis	MSAD 12 (Jackman, Moose River), MSAD 13 (Bingham, Caratunk, Moscow), MSAD 74 (Anson, Embden, New Portland, Solon), Dennistown, West Forks, The Forks, Caratunk, Pleasant Ridge	Reorganization – 1,283	Yes	Incomplete	Mills*	Pinkham
Somerset, Waldo	MSAD 53 (Burnham, Detroit, Pittsfield), MSAD 59 (Athens, Brighton Plt, Madison, Starks)	Reorganization – 2,197	Yes	Incomplete	Mills* Weston	Piotti Thomas
Waldo	MSAD 34 (Belfast, Belmont, Morrill, Northport, Searsmont, Swanville), MSAD 56 (Frankfort, Searsport, Stockton Springs)	Reorganization – 2,659	Yes	Incomplete	Weston	Walker Thibodeau
Waldo	MSAD 3 (Brooks, Freedom, Jackson, Knox, Liberty, Monroe, Montville, Thorndike, Troy, Unity, Waldo)	Alternative – 1,516	Yes	Incomplete	Weston	Cotta Walker Piotti Thibodeau
Washington	Calais, Alexander, Robbinston, Baring, Crawford, Charlotte, Perry, Baileyville, Cooper, Grand Lake Stream, Meddybemps, Eastport, Princeton, Talmadge, Waite, Topsfield, Pembroke, Codyville, Dennysville, Vanceboro (Unions 104, 106, 107, part 108)	Reorganization – 1,881	Yes	Incomplete	Raye Sherman	McLeod
Washington	Wesley, Northfield, Marshfield, Whitneyville, Jonesboro, Roque Bluffs, Machias, East Machias, Whiting, Cutler, Machiasport, MSAD 19 (Lubec) (Unions 102, 134)	Reorganization – 1,158	No	Does not comply	Raye	McFadden* Emery
Washington, Hancock	MSAD 37 (Addison, Cherryfield, Columbia, Columbia Falls, Harrington, Milbridge), Moosabec CSD, Peninsula CSD (Gouldsboro, Winter Harbor), Schoodic CSD (Sorrento, Sullivan), Flanders Bay CSD, Deblois, Beddington, Beals, Jonesport, Steuben, Franklin, Winter Harbor, Gouldsboro, Sullivan, Sorrento (Unions 96, 103)	Reorganization – 1,892	Yes	Incomplete	Damon Raye	Eaton Tibbetts
York	Acton	Reorganization - 403	No	Does not comply	Nass	Nass
York	Biddeford	Alternative – 2,782	Yes	Incomplete	Hobbins
York	Kittery	Letter (1,081)	No	Does not comply	Bowman*	Wheeler
York	MSAD 35 (Eliot, South Berwick)	Alternative – 2,576	Yes	Incomplete	Bowman*	Lewin
York	MSAD 57 (Alfred, Limerick, Lyman, Newfield, Shapleigh, Waterboro)	Alternative – 3,633	Yes	Incomplete	Nass	Jacobsen
York	MSAD 60 (Berwick, Lebanon, North Berwick)	Alternative – 3,090	Yes	Incomplete	Nass	Nass
York	MSAD 71 (Kennebunk, Kennebunkport), Arundel	Reorganization – 2,909	Yes	Incomplete	Sullivan	Babbidge
York	Old Orchard Beach, Saco, Dayton (Union 7)	Reorganization – 4,124	Yes	Incomplete	Hobbins	Valentino Connor
York	Sanford	Alternative – 3,450	Yes	Incomplete	Courtney	Nass
York	York, Wells-Ogunquit CSD	Reorganization – 3,383	Yes	Incomplete	Bowman* Nass	Weaver Chase
York, Cumberland	MSAD 6 (Buxton, Frye Island, Hollis, Limington, Standish)	Alternative – 4,146	Yes	Incomplete	Hobbins Diamond Courtney	Farrington*

Island and Tribal School Plans Submitted

County	Submitted Configuration	Type of Plan – Student Count	Configuration meets criteria in the law	Plan status
Cumberland	Chebeague Island	Alternative – Island  (39)	Yes	Incomplete		Burgess*
Cumberland	Long Island	Alternative – Island  (27)	Yes	Incomplete	Turner	Burgess*
Hancock	MSAD 7 (North Haven)	Alternative – Island  (65)	Yes	Incomplete		Pingree
Knox	MSAD 8 (Vinalhaven)	Alternative – Island  (206)	Yes	Incomplete		Pingree
Knox	Isle au Haut	Alternative – Island  (9)	Yes	Incomplete		Pingree
Knox	MSAD 65 (Matinicus)	Alternative – Island  (6)	Yes	Incomplete
Lincoln	Monhegan Island	Alternative – Island  (7)	Yes	Incomplete	Dow	McKane
Penobscot	Indian Island	Alternative – Tribal  (148)	Yes	Incomplete
Waldo	Islesboro	Alternative – Island  (77)	Yes	Incomplete	Weston	Walker
Washington	Indian Township	Alternative – Tribal  (176)	Yes	Incomplete
Washington	Pleasant Point	Alternative – Tribal  (164)	Yes	Incomplete

*Members of Education Committee